Name: Tony's N.y. Pizza
Price range: $$

Tony's N.y. Pizza Information

When you're craving a slice of pizza that's just as cozy as it is delicious, Tony's N.Y. Pizza in Marco Island, Florida, is the place to go. Located at 145 S Barfield Dr, this spot brings a bit of that classic New York vibe to the Gulf Coast, and it does so in a way that feels like home. It’s the kind of place where you walk in and immediately feel at ease, whether you're a local or just visiting.

The menu at Tony’s is everything you’d expect from a great pizzeria-filled with fresh ingredients, simple yet flavorful combinations, and a wide range of options to satisfy any craving. Of course, their pizza is the star of the show. Whether you opt for a classic New York-style slice or something a bit more adventurous, you won’t be disappointed. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy with that signature foldable texture that’s so satisfying. A slice with a crisp, tangy sauce, and gooey melted cheese is everything a good pizza should be. Their specialty pizzas, like the meat lover’s and white pizza, are incredibly popular among regulars.

But it’s not all about pizza here. If you’re in the mood for something else, the menu offers a selection of pasta dishes that are just as tasty. The spaghetti with meatballs is a crowd favorite, hearty and filling, with a rich sauce that’s the perfect balance of savory and sweet. They also serve up some fantastic subs, with the Italian sub standing out as one of the best on the menu-loaded with cold cuts and topped with just the right amount of seasoning.

The atmosphere at Tony's feels like a classic neighborhood joint, with friendly service and an environment that encourages you to sit back and relax. The staff are always attentive, making sure you have everything you need to enjoy your meal without feeling rushed. Even if it’s busy, they make sure you feel welcome, which is something you don’t always find in larger restaurants.

It’s clear that this place has earned its solid reputation, with glowing reviews from locals and visitors alike. The consistency of the food and the laid-back vibe make Tony’s a go-to spot for anyone in the area. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice to go or settling in for a full meal with friends and family, Tony's N.Y. Pizza provides a satisfying dining experience that’ll have you coming back for more. If you’re in Marco Island and craving pizza, this is a place you won’t want to miss.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

Great food. We shared a pizza and the meatball appetizer. The small in dinning was full when we ate there at dinner time on a Friday night. The place was busy with take out orders. The staff was friendly and attentive to our needs while eating in. This place is one of our favorites when we visit the island to escape the cold from the Midwest.

Exactly what you expect from a pizza joint. New York memorabilia on the wall, red and white checkered tablecloths and extremely good pizza. When working on this side of the island, we have to come to Tony's. Sometimes we'll come in here 3 days in a row. The cheese is as good as the sauce and they are both as good as the crust. They don't skimp out on the extra cheese, . Best pizza on Marco in my opinion.

This pizza place was a pleasant surprise! We were in a pinch for lunch one day on vacation and did a takeout of just a single pizza. We loved it all so much we ordered dinner there later in the week with multiple pizzas, pastas, and salads. If I'm back in Marco Island, I'll be making sure this is a place to stop again!

Awesome pizza we had delivered via doordash. We had the pasta fagioli soup, a slice of the Manhattan, garlic knots and two custom pizzas - pepperoni, jalapeno, banana peppers on NY crust and a gluten free crust supreme. The soup was delicious and the pizzas were all good in different ways. We agreed the gluten free crust was the most crispy and you barely tell it was GF. The only lowlight was the garlic knots which weren't very garlicky and seemed underproofed as they were dense and claggy. That's probably the only thing I wouldn't order again.

Fabulous spot to grab a meal. We ate in the restaurant but they do a big business in take out. The place was packed on a Thursday night! The eggplant pizza was huge and loaded with eggplant and cheese, my husband had the Caesar salad with grilled chicken that was also a very generous portion. Prices were very reasonable. I will definitely be back.

So we are from NY born and raised. I have not had the pizza but wife has and she said it is legit NY pizza. Very friendly and quick service.

Started off with the garlic knots which had the perfect texture to them. Then the BBQ & milk wings were some of the best wings I have ever tried! The pizza tasted so delicious and it wasn't as greasy as most pizza is!

From Chicago and this pizza is incredible! 9 cute tables that offer pizza by the slice, but we picked ours up and gave a quick heat up again at 450 for about 4-5 minutes. By far, the BEST pizza on the island with a crisp and thin crust! It’s a 10+ for sure!

Tony's N.y. Pizza

Tony's N.y. Pizza Information

Most Popular Dishes

Open Times

Tony's N.y. Pizza Gallery

Business Info

Location & Contact

What People's Say About Place

Places Nearby

Chocolate Fish Coffee Roasters

Capriccio

Greenberry's Coffee Co.

Las Margaritas Ocoee St.

Hamburger Heaven

Crossroads Cafe